The Benjamin Button Effect

Shackelford Funeral Directors • February 25, 2016

A long time ago in what seemed like a faraway place, a friend of mine watched as his father died of cancer. It was a death years in the making with each just a little worse than the previous. When the end finally came, it came with a vengeance and suffering that refused to be alleviated. And when it was all said and done with the last amen spoken and the crowd dispersed, he looked at me and asked, “Why does it have to be this way?”

At that moment his question could have prompted at least a dozen different answers, mainly because I didn’t really understand what he was asking. But later conversations revealed the frustration that many families experience when there is immense suffering preceding death. Why does someone work hard all of their lives, struggle to support their families and make ends meet, try to always do what they should do, only to be “rewarded” with pain and suffering and a departure that is anything but easy?

His concept of how it should be mirrored F. Scott Fitzgerald’s short story, “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”, something I’m fairly certain he’d never read and which Brad Pitt had not yet brought to life. Why couldn’t birth take place at a ripe old age, emerging from the earth rather than the womb, with all the infirmities and frailties that come with age? But as the years pass, our bodies could grow stronger and the wisdom gained with age would be ours in the beginning. Eventually, the knowledge of our years would gradually wane, not in the dementia of old age but in the innocence of youth. Our last years on this earth would be spent in the carefree joy of childhood until at last, we simply faded away.

If I allow the creative side of my brain to experience this reversal of the aging process, I can see where life might not be so filled with dread as the years progress. One would not have to worry about how they would survive or who would care for them or what would happen to them when they could no longer manage on their own. But if the logical side of my brain ever gets hold of the scenario, all havoc breaks lose.

As nice as all of the foregoing might be, someone much smarter than I am and certainly wiser deemed that it would be as it is. I will never understand why Death has to come as it does, bringing with it the pain and suffering not only of the dying but of those who survive. But come it will and in its own good time; our best revenge is to make the most of life before it arrives.

By Lisa Thomas September 11, 2025
The name they had chosen was filled with meaning, a combination of his father’s—Jon—and her father’s—Michael. Even before they knew what he was, they knew who he was.
By Lisa Thomas September 3, 2025
It was sometime in the 1960s or perhaps even the early 1970s. We could possibly even narrow it down a bit more than that . . . let’s say the mid-60s to early 70s. There had been a murder . . .
By Lisa Thomas August 27, 2025
“Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me.”
By Lisa Thomas August 20, 2025
Carl Jeter had walked out on the deck of his house to survey the flood waters of the Guadalupe River—and to be certain the level was no longer rising.
By Lisa Thomas August 13, 2025
It was bedtime in the Guinn household and six-year-old Malcolm had decided tonight was the night to declare his independence.
By Lisa Thomas August 6, 2025
They had been married almost 25 years when Death suddenly took him. Twenty-five years of traveling around the country with his work. Twenty-five years of adventures and building their family and finally settling into a place they believed they could call their forever home.
By Lisa Thomas July 30, 2025
It was quietly hiding in the chaos that was once a well-organized, barn-shaped workshop/storage building, one now filled with all the things no one needed but with which they couldn’t bring themselves to part.
By Lisa Thomas July 23, 2025
Do you remember when new vehicles didn’t come with on-board navigation systems and if you wanted one you had to buy something like a Garmin or a Magellan or some other brand that would talk you through your trip?
By Lisa Thomas July 16, 2025
Recently I found myself playing a rousing game of “Chutes and Ladders” with my grandson and his mom (my daughter)—a game I soon realized I was destined to lose.
By Lisa Thomas July 10, 2025
Facebook is like the double-edged sword of social media. On the one hand, it can be the spreader of good news . . . But it also serves as the bearer of all that is bad.